Great thread. Although I'm frankly shocked I'm the only one with this #1 pick, one of the band's greatest songs, period.
1. Meatmotherfuckinplow
2. Vaseline
3. Tumble in the Rough
4. Interstate Love Song
5. Sin
6. No Way Out
7. Trippin'
8. Too Cool Queenie (outdoes Piece of Pie by only a gnat's wing)
9. Plush (wow, this was by far the easiest, with the exception of Plush, #9s are a real weak spot for STP)
10. MC5
11. Atlanta
12. Seven Caged Tigers
13. Long Way Home (this has to be a given since it's the only track 13)
This didn't exactly play out the way I would have thought-- would have thought my favorite albums get the most representation, but overall, it was pretty even. Although SLDD I feel is the weakest of the 5 records, and it would have had only 1 song here had it not been for the obligatory #13.
Purple - 3
Tiny Music - 3
No. 4 - 3
Core - 2
SLDD - 2