Grade each STP song individually from 1-10

[robrhre]

I am aware there are threads somewhat similar to this, but I could not find one exactly the same, so here it goes. Yes, I have time to kill, waiting for my nephews birthday party, lol. One final thought, rate this by STP standards not cinsidering how it compares to the rest of music. If I did not do it by STP's standards then most would get a nine or higher and that is no fun. Tough grading makes it easier to distinguish how you really feel about the songs.

         CORE

1. Dead & Bloated 10
2. Sex Type Thing 10
3. Wicked Garden 10
4. No Memory/Sin 7.9
5. Naked Sunday 10
6. Creep 10
7. Piece of Pie 10
8. Crackerman 10
9. Where the River Goes 6.4
10. Plush 9.6
       Purple
1. Meatplow 8.8
2. Vasoline 10
3. Lounge Fly 4
4. Interstate Love Song 10
5. Still Remains 9.6
6. Pretty Penny 6.8
7. Silvergun Superman 9.9
8. Big Empty 10
9. Unglued 8.9
10. Army Ants 7.8
11. Kitchenware & Candybars 9.3
       Tiny Music
1. Pop's Love Suicide 8.4
2. Tumble in the Rough 8.6
3. Big Bang Baby 8.9
4. Lady Picture Show 8.7
5. And So I Know 6
6. Trippin 10
7. Art School Girl 9.3
8. Adhesive 8.9
9. Ride the Cliche 8.6
10. Daisy 6.9
11. Seven Caged Tigers 10
        No.4
1.Down 9.5
2. Heaven & Hot Rods 9.7
3. Pruno 9.2
4. Church on Tuesday 8.4
5. Sour Girl 9.8
6. No Way Out 10
7. Sex & Violence 10
8. Glide 6
9. I Got You 5.3
10. MC5 6.9
11. Atlanta 4
     SLDD
1. Dumb Love 10
2. Days of the Week 10
3. Coma 10
4. Hollywood Bitch 8.6
5. Wonderful 3
6. Black Again 7.4
7. Hello it's Late 6.3
8. Too Cool Queenie 8.8
9. Regeneration 8.3
10. Bi-Polar Bear 2.3
11. Transmission... 7
12. A Song for Sleeping 5.7
13. Long Way Home 8.9
       STP
1. Between the Lines 9.99999999999
2. Take a Load Off 9.3
3. Huckleberry Crumble 9.999999999
4. Hickory Dichotomy 9.99999999999
5. Dare If You Dare 9.9999999999999
6. Cinnamon 10 ( Stop hating on this song, it is very good)
7. Hazy Dazy 9.3
8. Bagman 8.6
9. Peacoat 6.3
10. Fast As I Can 8.4
11. First Kiss On Mars 9.999999999999
12. Maver 6.8
 
 
The songs that received a 9.9999999999 and not a ten was because they need to stand the test of time to be placed with the classics.
 

[Silver guns and Candybars]

thats alot of songs to grade! ill just give my highest/lowest rank on a scale 1-10
highest: regeneration 11
lowest: cinnamon 2
everything else is a 9 or a 10
besides you days of the week. you are a 7

[Aylin]

Wow you gave Atlanta and Loungefly 4 each...

I'm gonna do this when I have some time...

[wickedgarden23]

Lounge Fly a 4?!?! Wow I didnt think it was possible for an STP fan to dislike that song

[JoHAN_SOLO]

CORE
1. Dead & Bloated 8
2. Sex Type Thing 9
3. Wicked Garden 9
4. No Memory/Sin 7
5. Naked Sunday 6
6. Creep 8
7. Piece of Pie 7
8. Crackerman 8
9. Where the River Goes 7
10. Plush 8

PURPLE
1. Meatplow 9
2. Vasoline 9
3. Lounge Fly 9
4. Interstate Love Song 9
5. Still Remains 7
6. Pretty Penny 8
7. Silvergun Superman 9
8. Big Empty 9
9. Unglued 9
10. Army Ants 9
11. Kitchenware & Candybars 10

TINY MUSIC
1. Pop's Love Suicide 8
2. Tumble in the Rough 9
3. Big Bang Baby 8
4. Lady Picture Show 9
5. And So I Know 8
6. Trippin 10
7. Art School Girl 9,5
8. Adhesive 10
9. Ride the Cliche 8
10. Daisy 6
11. Seven Caged Tigers 9
 
NO.4
1.Down 10
2. Heaven & Hot Rods 9
3. Pruno 8
4. Church on Tuesday 9
5. Sour Girl 9
6. No Way Out 10
7. Sex & Violence 10
8. Glide 8
9. I Got You 8
10. MC5 10
11. Atlanta 10

SHANGRI-LA DEE DA
1. Dumb Love 7
2. Days of the Week 7
3. Coma 6
4. Hollywood Bitch 7
5. Wonderful 7
6. Black Again 7
7. Hello it's Late 8
8. Too Cool Queenie 8
9. Regeneration 7
10. Bi-Polar Bear 9
11. Transmission From A lonely Room 6
12. A Song for Sleeping 9
13. Long Way Home 9

STONE TEMPLE PILOTS
1. Between the Lines 8
2. Take a Load Off 7
3. Huckleberry Crumble 9
4. Hickory Dichotomy 9
5. Dare If You Dare 7
6. Cinnamon 7
7. Hazy Daze 7
8. Bagman 6
9. Peacoat 7
10. Fast As I Can 8
11. First Kiss On Mars 10
12. Maver 7

[robrhre]

Lounge Fly a 4?!?! Wow I didnt think it was possible for an STP fan to dislike that song

I feel the same way when people insult Cinnamon. Lounge Fly just never did anything for me, it has a weird sound and is very boring to me.

[Stop That Pigeon]

Lounge Fly a 4?!?! Wow I didnt think it was possible for an STP fan to dislike that song

I feel the same way when people insult Cinnamon. Lounge Fly just never did anything for me, it has a weird sound and is very boring to me.

That's a fair point imo. I love it that opinions vary so much - it's the sign of a creative group and fans who can differentiate & appreciate different things.

Having said that, I can't grade individual songs - STP is and remains an albums band for me.

[robrhre]

Your 100% right they are an albums band, not a band that has a few good songs on each record. That is why I thought it would be fun to examine each more thoroughly, rather than just the albums.

[pjstp]

CORE
1. Dead & Bloated 8
2. Sex Type Thing 9
3. Wicked Garden 9
4. No Memory/Sin 8.5
5. Naked Sunday 7
6. Creep 9
7. Piece of Pie 6
8. Crackerman 9
9. Where the River Goes 6
10. Plush 9       
Purple
1. Meatplow 10
2. Vasoline 10
3. Lounge Fly 8
4. Interstate Love Song 10
5. Still Remains 8
6. Pretty Penny 8
7. Silvergun Superman 8
8. Big Empty 10
9. Unglued 8.5
10. Army Ants 10
11. Kitchenware & Candybars 7

       Tiny Music
1. Pop's Love Suicide 10

2. Tumble in the Rough 8

3. Big Bang Baby 10

4. Lady Picture Show 9.5

5. And So I Know 10

6. Trippin 10
7. Art School Girl 8

8. Adhesive 9.5

9. Ride the Cliche 9

10. Daisy 8

11. Seven Caged Tigers 10
        No.4
1.Down 7

2. Heaven & Hot Rods 8.5

3. Pruno 8

4. Church on Tuesday 10

5. Sour Girl 10

6. No Way Out 8.5

7. Sex & Violence 8

8. Glide 9

9. I Got You 9.5

10. MC5 6

11. Atlanta 9.5

     SLDD
1. Dumb Love 7

2. Days of the Week 8

3. Coma 8

4. Hollywood Bitch 8

5. Wonderful 7.5

6. Black Again 7.5

7. Hello it's Late 9

8. Too Cool Queenie 8

9. Regeneration 6

10. Bi-Polar Bear 10

11. Transmission... 7
12. A Song for Sleeping 8

13. Long Way Home 9

       STP
1. Between the Lines 8.5

2. Take a Load Off 10

3. Huckleberry Crumble 7

4. Hickory Dichotomy 8.5

5. Dare If You Dare 9.5

6. Cinnamon 8

7. Hazy Dazy 6.9

8. Bagman 8
9. Peacoat 6

10. Fast As I Can 10

11. First Kiss On Mars 8

12. Maver 8

[Unglued]

   CORE
1. Dead & Bloated 9
2. Sex Type Thing 8.5
3. Wicked Garden 10
4. No Memory/Sin 9
5. Naked Sunday 8
6. Creep 8
7. Piece of Pie 9
8. Crackerman 10
9. Where the River Goes 9
10. Plush 10
       Purple
1. Meatplow 9
2. Vasoline 10
3. Lounge Fly 9.5
4. Interstate Love Song 9
5. Still Remains 9.5
6. Pretty Penny 9
7. Silvergun Superman 10
8. Big Empty 9
9. Unglued 10
10. Army Ants 10
11. Kitchenware & Candybars 9.5
       Tiny Music
1. Pop's Love Suicide 10
2. Tumble in the Rough 9
3. Big Bang Baby 9
4. Lady Picture Show 9
5. And So I Know 9
6. Trippin 10
7. Art School Girl 9
8. Adhesive 8
9. Ride the Cliche 9.5
10. Daisy 8
11. Seven Caged Tigers 8
        No.4
1.Down 9
2. Heaven & Hot Rods 10
3. Pruno 9.5
4. Church on Tuesday 9.5
5. Sour Girl 9.5
6. No Way Out 9
7. Sex & Violence 9
8. Glide 9
9. I Got You 5
10. MC5 9
11. Atlanta 10
     SLDD
1. Dumb Love 9
2. Days of the Week 8
3. Coma 8.5
4. Hollywood Bitch 8.5
5. Wonderful 7
6. Black Again 7.5
7. Hello it's Late 8
8. Too Cool Queenie 8
9. Regeneration 9
10. Bi-Polar Bear 4
11. Transmission... 6
12. A Song for Sleeping 6
13. Long Way Home 6
       STP
1. Between the Lines 9
2. Take a Load Off 9
3. Huckleberry Crumble 8.5
4. Hickory Dichotomy 8.5
5. Dare If You Dare 3
6. Cinnamon 8.5
7. Hazy Dazy 10
8. Bagman 9
9. Peacoat 9.5
10. Fast As I Can 9
11. First Kiss On Mars 8.5
12. Maver 4
 

[stpunderground]

CORE
1. Dead & Bloated 9
2. Sex Type Thing 9
3. Wicked Garden 10
4. No Memory/Sin 10
5. Naked Sunday 9
6. Creep 8
7. Piece of Pie 10
8. Crackerman 10
9. Where the River Goes 10
10. Plush 9.5
       Purple
1. Meatplow 9
2. Vasoline 10
3. Lounge Fly 5
4. Interstate Love Song 9
5. Still Remains 10
6. Pretty Penny 10
7. Silvergun Superman 9
8. Big Empty 10
9. Unglued 10
10. Army Ants 9.5
11. Kitchenware & Candybars 10
       Tiny Music
1. Pop's Love Suicide 10
2. Tumble in the Rough 10
3. Big Bang Baby 9
4. Lady Picture Show 10
5. And So I Know 10
6. Trippin 10
7. Art School Girl 9.5
8. Adhesive 10
9. Ride the Cliche 9.5
10. Daisy 8
11. Seven Caged Tigers 11
        No.4
1.Down 9
2. Heaven & Hot Rods 10
3. Pruno 9.5
4. Church on Tuesday 9.5
5. Sour Girl 9.5
6. No Way Out 10
7. Sex & Violence 10
8. Glide 10
9. I Got You 10
10. MC5 9.5
11. Atlanta 10
     SLDD
1. Dumb Love 9
2. Days of the Week 8
3. Coma 9
4. Hollywood Bitch 10
5. Wonderful 7
6. Black Again 9
7. Hello it's Late 8
8. Too Cool Queenie 9
9. Regeneration 10
10. Bi-Polar Bear 9.5
11. Transmission... 9
12. A Song for Sleeping 9
13. Long Way Home 9
       STP
1. Between the Lines 9
2. Take a Load Off 9
3. Huckleberry Crumble 6
4. Hickory Dichotomy 10
5. Dare If You Dare 10
6. Cinnamon 5
7. Hazy Dazy 8
8. Bagman 9.5
9. Peacoat 9.5
10. Fast As I Can 9.5
11. First Kiss On Mars 4
12. Maver 10
 
tiny music and no. 4 are my favorite albums and get the most play for me
 
i agree with the statement above saying STP is an albums band... and it was hard to rate and not give practically every song a 10.. songs that get the least play from me would be lounge fly, cinnamon, and first kiss on mars...just my least favorite by STP standards... i could still jam them anytime

[robrhre]

I think each one of us who did not give Plush a ten can blame that on the radio.

[stpunderground]

I think each one of us who did not give Plush a ten can blame that on the radio.

plush still gets airplay like its 1993 here in tampa
 
vasoline and dead and bloated are played to death as well... as far as the other hits they recieve moderate play... guarenteed to here like 3 stp songs a day on the radios here

[cosmicpilot]

I think each one of us who did not give Plush a ten can blame that on the radio.

YES!

[robrhre]

I have to go back in and give Too Cool Queenie a new grade, a 10.