List Favorite to Least Favorite Studio STP tunes

[JugeSTP]

I was on a VERY long layover yesterday coming back from New Orleans and incredibly bored, so I listed STP's tune from favorite to least favorite. I went to the Saints game, by the way, are we're SuperBowl bound! Woohoo.

Ok so here's what I came up with:

1 Silvergun Superman
2 Down
3 Trippin' on a Hole in a Paper Heart
4 Vasoline
5 All in the Suit that you Wear
6 Crackerman
7 Kitchenware & Candybars
8 Interstate Love Song
9 Coma
10 Seven Caged Tigers
11 Meatplow
12 Wicked Garden
13 No Way Out
14 Dead & Bloated
15 Heaven & Hotrods
16 Naked Sunday
17 Lounge Fly
18 Wonderful
19 Sex Type Thing
20 Sin
21 Big Empty
22 Press Play
23 Army Ants
24 Dumb Love
25 Unglued
26 Tumble in the Rough
27 Piece of Pie
28 Pop's Love Suicide
29 Ride the Cliche
30 Hollywood Bitch
31 Plush
32 Still Remains
33 Glide
34 Atlanta
35 Where the River Goes
36 Sour Girl
37 Church on Tuesday
38 Big Bang Baby
39 Too Cool Queenie
40 Pretty Penny
41 Hello It's Late
42 Adhesive
43 Transmissions from a Lonely Room
44 Creep
45 Pruno
46 Long Way Home
47 No Memory
48 Wet My Bed
49 A Song For Sleeping
50 Sex & Violence
51 I Got You
52 And So I Know
53 Regeneration
54 Days of the Week
55 Art School Girl
56 Lady Picture Show
57 Daisy
58 Black Again
59 MC5
60 Pi Bolar Bear

That's all I could come up, so I think they have 60 original studio songs. I'm not counting the Might Joe Young Demo, the hidden track on Purple or Dancing Days.

So then I did a little equation to figure out which album rated the highest based on this ranking. Yes, very dorky.

Average ranking of Core song: 26.58
Average ranking of Purple song: 17.18
Average ranking of Tiny Music song: 31.25
Average ranking of #4 song: 34
Average ranking of Shangri-La song: 40.30

So I was a little surprised to see that my albums from favorite to least favorite are:

Purple
Core
Tiny Music
#4
Shangri-La Dee Da

I don't recommend anyone else take the time to do this, but I am interested in your take none the less.

[STP92]

Ah, what the hell. I already had the top 40 on my itunes.

1. Plush
2. Big Empty
3. Kitchenware & Candybars
4. Trippin' on a Hole in a Paper Heart
5. Interstate Love Song
6. Wicked Garden
7. Still Remains
8. Lounge Fly
9. Sex Type Thing
10. Vasoline
11. Dead & Bloated
12. Silvergun Superman
13. Lady Picture Show
14. Army Ants
15. Adhesive
16. Pop's Love Suicide
17. Meatplow
18. Crackerman
19. I Got You
20. Seven Caged Tigers
21. No Way Out
22. Big Bang Baby
23. No Memory/Sin
24. Tumble in the Rough
25. Dumb Love
26. Down
27. Atlanta
28. Hello It's Late
29. Glide
30. Sex & Violence
31. Transmissions from a Lonely Room
32. Sour Girl
33. Creep
34. Wonderful
35. And So I Know
36. Long Way Home
37. Piece of Pie
38. Coma
39. Bi-Polar Bear
40. Art School Girl
41. Black Again
42. Naked Sunday
43. Heaven & Hot Rods
44. Unglued
45. Ride the Cliche
46. Where the River Goes
47. Pretty Penny
48. Church on Tuesday
49. Too Cool Queenie
50. Hollywood Bitch
51. Regeneration
52. Days of the Week
53. Press Play
54. MC5
55. Wet My Bed
56. Pruno
57. Daisy
58. A Song for Sleeping

Wow, that was hard!

[Lazy Divey]

I don't think I can chose just one song to top them all so I'll do my rankings by album

Core -

Sin
Naked Sunday
Piece of Pie
Crackerman
Dead and Bloated
Sex Type Thing
Wicked Garden
Plush
Where the River Goes
Creep
No Memory
Wet My Bed

Purple-

Unglued
Interstate Love Song
Silvergun Superman
Vasoline
Meat Plow
Lounge Fly
Kitchenware and Candybars
Pretty Penny
Big Empty
Still Remains
Army Ants

Tiny Music-

Trippin on a Hole in a Paper Heart
Big Bang Baby
Adhesive
Lady Picture Show
Tumble in the Rough
Seven Caged Tigers
Pop's Love Suicide
And So I know
Art School Girl
Ride the Cliche
Daisy
Press Play

No. 4-

Sour Girl
Heaven and Hotrods
Pruno
Atlanta
Sex and Violence
I Got You
MC5
Down
Church on Tuesday
Glide
No Way Out

Shangri La Dee Da-

Bi Polar Bear
Transmissions from a Lonely Room
Hello it's Late
Long Way Home
Regeneration
Too Cool Queenie
Wonderful
Hollywood Bitch
Dumb Love
Coma
Black Again
Days of the Week
A Song for Sleeping

[wickedgarden23]

haha I've done similar rankings before JugeSTP, so you're not the only nerd here lol. I ranked each song on a scale of 1 to 10, then came up with averages for each album:

Core average: 8.6
1. Plush
2. Sex Type Thing
3. Piece Of Pie
4. Sin
5. Wicked Garden
6. Crackerman
7. Dead & Bloated
8. Naked Sunday
9. Where The River Goes
10. No Memory
11. Creep
12. Wet My Bed

Purple average: 8.1
1. Silvergun Superman
2. Lounge Fly
3. Big Empty
4. Vasoline
5. Still Remains
6. Meatplow
7. Interstate Love Song
8. Army Ants
9. Unglued
10. Kitchenware & Candy Bars
11. Pretty Penny

Tiny Music... average: 7.75
1. Trippin'
2. And So I Know
3. Big Bang Baby
4. Pop's Love Suicide
5. Ride The Cliche
6. Adhesive
7. Tumble In The Rough
8. Lady Picture Show
9. Seven Caged Tigers
10. Artschool Girl
11. Press Play
12. Daisy

No. 4 average: 7.4
1. Down
2. Heaven & Hot Rods
3. Pruno
4. Glide
5. Church On Tuesday
6. No Way Out
7. I Got You
8. Sour Girl
9. Sex & Violence
10. Atlanta
11. MC5

Shangri-La average: 7.7
1. Transmissions From A Lonely Room
2. Coma
3. Dumb Love
4. Long Way Home
5. Too Cool Queenie
6. Black Again
7. Bi-Polar Bear
8. Hollywood Bitch
9. Wonderful
10. Hello, It's Late
11. Days Of The Week
12. Regeneration
13. A Song For Sleeping

So there ya have it. With averaging out each album it makes it seem that even my favorite album (Core) would only be about a B+ but I've found that always seems to happen anytime you average all the songs together like I did. Also, I was not ranking them in relation to other songs by other artists, but only as STP songs if that makes sense.

[JugeSTP]

haha I've done similar rankings before JugeSTP, so you're not the only nerd here lol. I ranked each song on a scale of 1 to 10, then came up with averages for each album:

Core average: 8.6
1. Plush
2. Sex Type Thing
3. Piece Of Pie
4. Sin
5. Wicked Garden
6. Crackerman
7. Dead & Bloated
8. Naked Sunday
9. Where The River Goes
10. No Memory
11. Creep
12. Wet My Bed

Purple average: 8.1
1. Silvergun Superman
2. Lounge Fly
3. Big Empty
4. Vasoline
5. Still Remains
6. Meatplow
7. Interstate Love Song
8. Army Ants
9. Unglued
10. Kitchenware & Candy Bars
11. Pretty Penny

Tiny Music... average: 7.75
1. Trippin'
2. And So I Know
3. Big Bang Baby
4. Pop's Love Suicide
5. Ride The Cliche
6. Adhesive
7. Tumble In The Rough
8. Lady Picture Show
9. Seven Caged Tigers
10. Artschool Girl
11. Press Play
12. Daisy

No. 4 average: 7.4
1. Down
2. Heaven & Hot Rods
3. Pruno
4. Glide
5. Church On Tuesday
6. No Way Out
7. I Got You
8. Sour Girl
9. Sex & Violence
10. Atlanta
11. MC5

Shangri-La average: 7.7
1. Transmissions From A Lonely Room
2. Coma
3. Dumb Love
4. Long Way Home
5. Too Cool Queenie
6. Black Again
7. Bi-Polar Bear
8. Hollywood Bitch
9. Wonderful
10. Hello, It's Late
11. Days Of The Week
12. Regeneration
13. A Song For Sleeping

So there ya have it. With averaging out each album it makes it seem that even my favorite album (Core) would only be about a B+ but I've found that always seems to happen anytime you average all the songs together like I did. Also, I was not ranking them in relation to other songs by other artists, but only as STP songs if that makes sense.

hahaha, that's good stuff man. Very dorky, I like it! I should've done it like you. Next time I've got time on my hands I'm all over that.  

[JugeSTP]

Wow, A Song for Sleeping is getting hammered out there. Haha.

[Tyrant]

Wow, A Song for Sleeping is getting hammered out there. Haha.

I'll fix this.  

Core:
Piece Of Pie
Crackerman
Wicked Garden
Plush
Dead & Bloated
Sex Type Thing
No Memory
Sin
Naked Sunday
Wet My Bed
Where The River Goes
Creep

Purple:
Kitchenware & Candybars
Silvergun Superman
Lounge Fly
Big Empty
Still Remains
Interstate Love Song
Meatplow
Unglued
Army Ants
Vasoline
Pretty Penny

Tiny Music:
Seven Caged Tigers
Lady Picture Show
And So I Know
Trippin' On A Hole In A Paper Heart
Adhesive
Tumble In The Rough
Big Bang Baby
Ride The Cliché
Press Play
Pop's Love Suicide
Art School Girl
Daisy

No.4:
Atlanta
I Got You
Glide
Sour Girl
Down
Sex & Violence
Church On Tuesday
MC5
No Way Out
Heaven & Hot Rods
Pruno

Shangri-la Dee Da:
Hello It's Late
A Song For Sleeping
Wonderful
Bi-Polar Bear
Regeneration
Hollywood Bitch
Too Cool Queenie
Black Again
Coma
Days of the Week
Dumb Love
Transmissions From A Lonely Room
Long Way Home

[gravedancer]

Core:
Plush
Dead and Bloated
Sex Type Thing
Crackerman
Wicked Garden
Naked Sunday
Creep
Sin
Piece of Pie
Where The River Goes
No Memory
Wet My Bed

Purple:
Still Remains
Unglued
Interstate Love Song
Silvergun Superman
Lounge Fly
Big Empty
Vasoline
Army Ants
Meatplow
Kitchenware and Candybars
Pretty Penny

Tiny Music:
Trippin'
Seven Caged Tigers
Lady Picture Show
Adhesive
Big Bang Baby
Ride The Cliche
Art School Girl
And So I Know
Pops Love Suicide
Tumble In The Rough
Daisy
Press Play

No. 4:
Sour Girl
Down
I Got You
Glide
Atlanta
Church On Tuesday
MC5
No Way Out
Pruno
Heaven & Hot Rods
Sex & Violence

Shangri La Dee Da:
Too Cool Queenie
Long Way Home
Hello It's Late
Wonderful
Black Again
Transmission From a Lonely Room
Dumb Love
Coma
Hollywood Bitch
Days of The Week
Bi-Polar Bear
Regeneration
A Song For Sleeping

[andrew]

This is a difficult task.... Especially Purple. I love all of the songs.

Core:
Crackerman
Naked Sunday
Where The River Goes
Dead And Bloated
Wicked Garden
Piece Of Pie
Sin
Plush
Sex Type Thing
Wet My Bed
Creep
No Memory


Purple:
Still Remains
Meatplow
Kitchenware & Candybars
Vasoline
Silvergun Superman
Interstate Love Song
Lounge Fly
Army Ants
Big Empty
Unglued
Pretty Penny

Tiny Music:
Adhesive
Trippin' On A Hole In A Paper Heart
Seven Caged Tigers
Big Bang Baby
Tumble In The Rough
Lady Picture Show
And So I Know
Pop's Love Suicide
Ride The Cliche
Art School Girl
Press Play
Daisy


No. 4:
Glide
Heaven & Hot Rods
I Got You
Pruno
Church On Tuesday
Sex & Violence
Atlanta
No Way Out
Sour Girl
MC5
Down

Shangri La Dee Da:
Long Way Home
Hollywood Bitch
Coma
Bi-Polar Bear
Hello It's Late
Transmissions From A Lonely Room
A Song For Sleeping
Wonderful
Black Again
Dumb Love
Regeneration
Too Cool Queenie
Days Of The Week

[Shangri]

Wow, A Song for Sleeping is getting hammered out there. Haha.

Savior No 2!  

This is a difficult task.... Especially Purple. I love all of the songs.

Oh yes! Purple was untamable, so was SLDD.

I can't list all the songs together, it's just impossible for me...

Core
Wicked Garden
Where the river goes
Crackerman
Sex Type Thing
Wet my bed
No Memory
Creep
Nacked Sunday
Dead & Bloated
Piece of Pie
Sin
Plush

Purple
Big Empty
Silvergun Superman
Still Remains
Kitchenware & Candybars
Lounge Fly
Interstate love song
Vasoline
Meatplow
Pretty Penny
Unglued
Army Ants

Tiny Music
Trippin on a hole in a paper heart
Big Bang Baby
Adhesive
Seven Caged Tigers
Daisy
Lady Picture show
Art School Girl
And so I know
Tumble in the rough
Ride the Cliché
Press Play
Pop's Love Suicide

No 4
Atlanta
I got you
Down
Glide
Sour Girl
Sex & Violence
No way out
Heaven & hot rods
Church on Tuesday
Pruno
MC5

Shangri-La Dee Da
Hello, it's late
A song for sleeping
Bi-Polar Bear
Wondeful
Dumb Love
Long way home
Coma
Transmissions from a lonely room
Too Cool Queenie
Hollywood Bitch
Black Again
Days of the week
Regeneration

[zackrandal]

where the river goes
silvergun superman
no memory / sin
piece of pie
army ants
plush
dumb love
seven caged tigers
adhesive
naked sunday
down
big bang baby
unglued
big empty
wicked garden
crackerman
lounge fly
dead & bloated
long way home
meat plow
still remains
and so i know
pops love suicide
sex type thing
coma
lady picture show
vasoline
kitchenware & candybars
ride the cliche
interstate love song
days of the week
heaven and hot rods
glide
no way out
sex and violence
pretty penny
creep
mc5
trippin on a hole in a paper heart
art school girl
atlanta
tumble in the rough
then everything else on no.4 and shangri-la dee da

almost everything on the list is awesome regardless of where i put it though, its about at "days of the week" where it goes down a level to "just great". no.4 and shangri-la dee da are really ok, i just cant list most of their songs on the same level as "where the river goes" or "silvergun superman"

[wickedgarden23]

So there ya have it. With averaging out each album it makes it seem that even my favorite album (Core) would only be about a B+ but I've found that always seems to happen anytime you average all the songs together like I did. Also, I was not ranking them in relation to other songs by other artists, but only as STP songs if that makes sense.

oops i meant "rating" when I said ranking lol

[Silvergun92]

Core
1. Wicked Garden
2. Crackerman
3. Plush
4. Where the River Goes
5. Dead and Bloated
6. Sin
7. Piece of Pie
8. Naked Sunday
9.Creep
10. Wet My Bed
11. No Memory
12. Sex Type Thing

Purple
1. Still Remains
2. Big Empty
3. Interstate Love Song
4. Lounge Fly
5. Vasoline
6. Kitchenware & Candybars
7. Meatplow
8. Silvergun Superman
9. Unglued
10. Army Ants
11. Pretty Penny

Tiny Music...
1. Trippin' On A Hole In A Paper Heart
2. Adhesive
3. Seven Caged Tigers
4. Lady Picture Show
5. Big Bang Baby
6. Tumble in the Rough
7. Ride the Cliche
8. And So I Know
9. Pop's Love Suicide
10. Press Play
11. Daisy
12. Art School Girl

No. 4
1. Glide
2. Atlanta
3. Sour Girl
4. Down
5. I Got You
6. No Way Out
7. Pruno
8. Sex & Violence
9. Church on Tuesday
10. MC5
11. Heaven & Hot Rods

Shangri-La Dee Da
1. Bi-Polar Bear
2. Long Way Home
3. Hello It's Late
4. Hollywood Bitch
5. Wonderful
6. Coma
7. Transmissions From A Lonely Room
8. Too Cool Queenie
9. Dumb Love
10. Days of the Week
11. Regeneration
12. Black Again
13. A Song For Sleeping (Sorry )

[loungefly611]

-Core
Sex Type Thing
Crackerman
Wicked Garden
No Memory
Piece of Pie
Sin
Creep
Dead and Bloated
Plush
Naked Sunday
Where the River Goes
Wet My Bed

-Purple
Lounge Fly (Duh
Kitchenware and Candybars
Silvergun Superman
Interstate Love Song
Big Empty
Unglued
Vasoline
Still Remains
Army Ants
Pretty Penny
Meat Plow

-Tiny Music
Adhesive
Trippin on a Hole in a Paper Heart..
And So I Know
Tumble in the Rough
Art School Girl
Seven Caged Tigers
Big Bang Baby
Pop's Love Suicide
Lady Picture show
Daisy
Press Play
Ride the Cliché

-No.4
Down
Atlanta
Heaven & Hot Rods
Glide
I Got You
Sour Girl
No Way Out
Church on Tuesday
Sex & Violence
MC5
Pruno

-SLDD
Hello, It's Late
Too Cool Queenie
Hollywood Bitch
Coma
Wonderful
Bi-Polar Bear
Transmissions From a Lonely Room
Days of the Week
A Song For Sleeping
Dumb Love
Regeneration
Black Again
Long Way Home

It's impossible for me to rank every song. That would be a crazy task. But, I can tell you me least favorite song BY FAR is Pruno, followed by Long Way Home, Black Again, MC5, and probably Regeneration. I was going to say Ride The Cliche, but I've grown to like it more.

[Slither]

Core

Plush
Wicked Garden
Wet My Bed into Crackerman
No Memory into Sin
Piece of Pie
Creep
Where the River Goes
Dead and Bloated
Sex Type Thing
Naked Sunday


Purple

Still Remains
Interstate Love Song
Silvergun Superman
Lounge Fly
Big Empty
Unglued
Vasoline
Meatplow
Kitchenware
Army Ants
Pretty Penny


Tiny Music

Trippin on a Hole in a Paper Heart
Seven Caged Tigers
Lady Picture Show
Adhesive
Tumble in the Roughl
Big Bang Baby
And So I Know
Pop's Love Suicide
Daisy
Press Play
Ride the Cliché


No. 4

Atlanta
Down
Sour Girl
Glide
Heaven and Hotrods
Pruno
I Got You
No Way Out
Church on Tuesday
Sex & Violence
MC5


Shangri

Transmissions From a Lonely Room
Hello It's Late
Regeneration
Too Cool Queenie
Days of the Week
Hollywood Bitch
Coma
Wonderful
Long Way Home
A Song for Sleeping
Black Again
Dumb Love
Bi-Polar Bear

THAT WAS HARD