I think that this is a great song and an unexpected and positive change. I heard the song before this thread was started and I didn't know that Tim McGraw was involved. It doesn't matter to me since 1) the song's really good and 2) Tim wasn't in the performance.
Daniel Lanois' steel guitar and the steel drums are a great combo. I can't say I've heard anything like it before. I'd like to know who the other players are. Their matching suits and cowboy hats were great too. Musicall, it reminds me of the version of 'Sour Girl' played on Letterman with Junior Brown on lap steel. Definately my favorite version of SG.
Overall, I'm pleasently surprised that Scott and Tim and whoever was able push the music in this alterna-country song. It's not stupid and emo and it's not predictable, boring modern rock. It's refreshing. I wonder if a new album from Scott would sound like this? This song sounds like a mix of STP and Scott's solo sensibilities. Scott's bellowed vocal delivery sounded a little forced but other than that it was a great performance.