The Future Of STP?

[StoneTempleBrett]

Wasn't it confirmed that "Only Dying" was never re-recorded? From my understanding, that was just the original title of "Big Empty". I think Robert even mentioned they wouldn't be interested in re-recording it in the first place because they used parts of it in "Piece of Pie".

It was never re-recorded.  Scott told me it was written and demoed in 1991.

[STP92]

Wasn't it confirmed that "Only Dying" was never re-recorded? From my understanding, that was just the original title of "Big Empty". I think Robert even mentioned they wouldn't be interested in re-recording it in the first place because they used parts of it in "Piece of Pie".

It was never re-recorded.  Scott told me it was written and demoed in 1991.

That's what I thought.

On the topic of posthumous releases, I'd love to hear the original "The Way She Moves" or anything from the No.4/Shangri sessions we haven't heard.

[Sklashboombash]

Wasn't it confirmed that "Only Dying" was never re-recorded? From my understanding, that was just the original title of "Big Empty". I think Robert even mentioned they wouldn't be interested in re-recording it in the first place because they used parts of it in "Piece of Pie".

I remember something like that. Which part in Piece of Pie exactly, because I never picked it out.

[STP92]

Wasn't it confirmed that "Only Dying" was never re-recorded? From my understanding, that was just the original title of "Big Empty". I think Robert even mentioned they wouldn't be interested in re-recording it in the first place because they used parts of it in "Piece of Pie".

I remember something like that. Which part in Piece of Pie exactly, because I never picked it out.

I think it's the bridge of "Piece of Pie".

[Kingpetty]

What do any of you think about Billy Corgan or Chris Cornell fronting STP ? Yes, no, maybe. I realize they have their own projects going, but they may be a good fit. I think they would do a great job of honoring Scott's legacy. They both seem to have made amends w/ Scott in the past, or at the least, they very much appreciate Scott's phenominal talent. Of the 2, I think Cornell would be a better fit. His voice would be good for the STP catalog with them possibly releasing new material.

[Sklashboombash]

If the Deleos ever did anything with Cornell, I'm sure it'd be killer but I think there should be no more "fronting STP".

But I do hope they continue to make music, and I'd say, preferably with Eric...though that it would probably be a constant reminder of Scott being gone.

Aside from the obvious loss of Scott no longer walking this earth, another bit of my heart breaks as I feel like this also results in the possible end of Robert, Dean and Eric playing together. Hope I'm wrong about the second part.

[StoneTempleBrett]

What do any of you think about Billy Corgan or Chris Cornell fronting STP ? Yes, no, maybe. I realize they have their own projects going, but they may be a good fit. I think they would do a great job of honoring Scott's legacy. They both seem to have made amends w/ Scott in the past, or at the least, they very much appreciate Scott's phenominal talent. Of the 2, I think Cornell would be a better fit. His voice would be good for the STP catalog with them possibly releasing new material.

I'd rather hear them do a new band with either of those guys entirely focused on new music.

[Kingpetty]

If the Deleos ever did anything with Cornell, I'm sure it'd be killer but I think there should be no more "fronting STP".

But I do hope they continue to make music, and I'd say, preferably with Eric...though that it would probably be a constant reminder of Scott being gone.

Aside from the obvious loss of Scott no longer walking this earth, another bit of my heart breaks as I feel like this also results in the possible end of Robert, Dean and Eric playing together. Hope I'm wrong about the second part.

I think the remaining 3 will stick together, but you're correct, they may put STP to rest. Time will tell. Besides Robert & Delta Deep, I don't know of any side projects for Dean & Eric. I think the 3 of them plan on making music together as long as they're healthy & have that drive.

I don't see them starting over with a "Brand New" young upstart frontman. I would think they'd be looking for a "Veteran" of sorts, someone very familiar & appreciative of their history. We shall see what they name the band.

[Sklashboombash]

It's too bad nobody would care about a Talk Show record. I'd dig it.

But yes, hopefully they do rest the STP name. I really hope so, despite the Scott firing and eventual hiring of Chester.

[Kingpetty]

What do any of you think about Billy Corgan or Chris Cornell fronting STP ? Yes, no, maybe. I realize they have their own projects going, but they may be a good fit. I think they would do a great job of honoring Scott's legacy. They both seem to have made amends w/ Scott in the past, or at the least, they very much appreciate Scott's phenominal talent. Of the 2, I think Cornell would be a better fit. His voice would be good for the STP catalog with them possibly releasing new material.

I'd rather hear them do a new band with either of those guys entirely focused on new music.

I appreciate that point Brett & it would be just fine by me also. A nice way to carry on & leave STP'S legacy w/ Scott at rest. Thanks for your hard work & keeping us informed. I think there are some good things coming in the future whether they call themselves STP or not.

[Rol2292]

I don't think C organ or Cornell fit their vibe. I'd think a Chris Robinson or Lenny kravitz are more their type. Neither would happen, but it's just a thought. I'm

[CagedTiger]

Army of Anyone but with Kretz on drums is what I'd like to see, I think Richard would be down for that in the future, maybe not next year though as he'll be releasing and promoting the new Filter record then...

I really hope they retire the STP name now though.

[lovemachine97]

They could easily release Only Dying with a different name. I mean, until it is in print and officially released, they aren't tethered to anything.

As far as what they do, I have no idea, but with Scott dead the only thing that makes sense is retiring, a new band, or Chester with STP, or some combination of both. I mean, there is a part of me that thinks the occasional new tune and touring every couple years with Chester isn't all that ludicrous, but the STP guys would need a more permanent gig.

The irony now is that, if they are to continue as a new band, they need a frontman as viable as Scott was when he showed up with VR. That's pretty limiting right there. Maybe Chris Robinson. What is the history with that btw? It sounds familiar as a project, but at 37 I am starting to forget shit. Can someone remind me? Either way, Chris getting back to his more rocking roots with Rob, Dean, and Eric would be pretty awesome.

But at the end of the day, I honestly feel for the guys. I mean, they probably never, truly thought he would die while they were on bad terms. There is part of me that hopes we hear an interview soon that confirms they had at least forgiven each other.

I say that because it would be torture if you fired a guy because of his addictions, a lifelong friend, and then within 2 years of doing that, he dies due to those addictions and you never made amends. If that is how it went down, it will haunt those guys for years, unless they are fooling themselves.

In other words, since they were lifelong buddies of Scott's, whatever brings them peace I am behind.

[StoneTempleBrett]

Wasn't 'Shattered' what fans originally called it?

[ShaneC]

I believe the STP name needs to be laid to rest now, unless the Deleos maybe do an album with a bunch of different singers ("STP & Friends"?) and dedicate it to Scott.

I know I want to hear more from Kretz & the Deleos.